Discussion:
RIP Earl Scruggs
(too old to reply)
Tony Weber
2012-03-29 03:50:55 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
Carl
2012-03-29 14:09:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
I guess this is tongue in cheek, right?

It's a big loss to me, the marking of the ending of yet another great era in
music.
Kevin Hall
2012-03-29 15:30:07 UTC
Permalink
Post by Carl
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
I guess this is tongue in cheek, right?
It's a big loss to me, the marking of the ending of yet another great era
in music.
Pretty much defined banjo style and sound for 3 generations. One of the
original greats.

Reminds me of a banjo player at a festival years ago asking the audience "
Who is this Earl Scrubbs guy anyway?"

KH
Steve Daniels
2012-03-29 17:41:23 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 29 Mar 2012 11:30:07 -0400, against all advice, something
Post by Kevin Hall
Post by Carl
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
I guess this is tongue in cheek, right?
It's a big loss to me, the marking of the ending of yet another great era
in music.
Pretty much defined banjo style and sound for 3 generations. One of the
original greats.
Reminds me of a banjo player at a festival years ago asking the audience "
Who is this Earl Scrubbs guy anyway?"
He makes capos, right?
Post by Kevin Hall
KH
Mike Brown
2012-03-29 21:59:53 UTC
Permalink
Post by Carl
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
I guess this is tongue in cheek, right?
It's a big loss to me, the marking of the ending of yet another great era in
music.
Yes. I've got to the stage that most of the musicians who I grew up
listening to are gone.

If there is any such place as "heaven", they must have a "hell" of a
band up there.

MJRB
Carl
2012-03-30 04:29:09 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mike Brown
Post by Carl
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
I guess this is tongue in cheek, right?
It's a big loss to me, the marking of the ending of yet another
great era in music.
Yes. I've got to the stage that most of the musicians who I grew up
listening to are gone.
If there is any such place as "heaven", they must have a "hell" of a
band up there.
MJRB
You can't fool me. That comes from what was probably the last Righteous
Brothers hit in the '70's:

If you believe in forever
Then life is just a one night stand
If there's a rock n roll heaven
Well you know they've got a hell of a band.
Tony Weber
2012-03-29 23:14:48 UTC
Permalink
Post by Carl
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
I guess this is tongue in cheek, right?
Firmly.
Post by Carl
It's a big loss to me, the marking of the ending of yet another great era in
music.
Ain't that the sad truth.
Steven Bornfeld
2012-03-29 15:32:10 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
Heard an ecomium this morning on (of all places) WBBR, (Bloomberg business).

RIP.

Steve
--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001
Tony Done
2012-03-29 19:21:30 UTC
Permalink
"Tony Weber" wrote in message news:***@megapath.net...

Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?

*********************

RIP. I admired Earl's sheer musicality more than his technique, he had a
wonderful ear for chord substitutions and voicing. I think he would have
done well on any instrument he chose.

Tony D
harv
2012-03-30 07:17:53 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
*********************
RIP. I admired Earl's sheer musicality more than his technique, he had a
wonderful ear for chord substitutions and voicing. I think he would have
done well on any instrument he chose.
Tony D
I always liked the story about the time a young picker met Earl and
was telling him how he had spent 3 weeks learning a particular lick...
he played it for Earl and Earl says to the kid “... son... that was a
mistake...”

Herb Pedersen told me the story about the guy who showed him a banjo
with a compensated bridge, Earl played it and said, “nice banjo... but
the intonation is way off up the neck” Then he played his own and of
course the intonation was perfect as he stretched the strings the
further up he played.

Harv
Country
2012-03-29 22:21:26 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
Bummer, another of my favorite old timers gone. He didn't just play
the banjo. He played the hell out of the Banjo.

-C-
Tom from Texas
2012-03-30 14:47:08 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
I was talking to my mom about his death yesterday. She reminded me of
going to see Flatt and Scruggs north of Dallas when I was a kid. The
family care pulled up to the gate; Mom leaned out the window and asked
the man there "Is this where Flatt and Scruggs are playin' today?"
The man said yeah and gave us directions to park and get into the
festival. As we drove off, my dad told my mom that that was Earl
Scruggs. She loves that story.

Tom from Texas
p***@blueyonder.co.uk
2012-03-30 20:58:44 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
Another great one gone.

rip Earl
l***@yahoo.com
2012-03-31 02:45:20 UTC
Permalink
I'd like to think he was as nice a guy as he always seems to come
across as on film/videos.

That Complete Earl Scruggs video (that I bought the DVD of) is up on
YouTube.


a***@yahoo.com
2012-03-30 19:23:51 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
He was quite the man. I met him in New York back in the 70s. I got
there real early thinking the place would be swamped, but was able to
just walk in. And there he was - just sitting by the stage chatting
with his son Randy. No big ego, no faux humility or condescension,
just a simple, likable guy.

He made banjo playing look effortless - sometimes even looked like he
was daydreaming when he played. Randy was intense, though - he played
Black Mountain Rag that night - on a cello! - hung all over the
instrument like a mad scientist, long hair flying, in a cloud of rosin
powder - pretty wild. Earl just stood by, with a little smile on his
face, then calmly stepped up to the mike for his break, kinda looking
around and at the ceiling, then stepping back when he was done. Just
another guy in the band.

I have an old record with an interview of him saying he wanted to play
all types of music on the banjo. They play everything on other
instruments, "why not the banjo?" And he did. Awesome talent.

Rest in Peace. See ya later.

peace and joy,
jbj
Dan Kozar
2012-04-05 05:22:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
He did quite fine on guitar as well!!
Tony Done
2012-04-05 08:06:42 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.

Harv

***************

I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.

Tony D
Jonathan
2012-04-05 14:31:38 UTC
Permalink
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.

I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.

Thanks,
Jonathan
hank alrich
2012-04-05 15:02:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jonathan
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar * http://hankalrich.com/
http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusic
http://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Tom from Texas
2012-04-05 18:30:19 UTC
Permalink
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
Tuning? Banjo? Standard? Can those three words be used in the same
sentence?

Tom from Texas
hank alrich
2012-04-05 18:41:44 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tom from Texas
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was
kind of homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition
being a great player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
Tuning? Banjo? Standard? Can those three words be used in the same
sentence?
Tom from Texas
Move along, This doesn't concern you. Nothing to see here.

Next??

Do note that Earl's book is not a good place for a beginner to start.
Pete Wernick's is a worthy offering, and once a student is well into
that one Earl's can be a good next step.
--
shut up and play your guitar * http://hankalrich.com/
http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusic
http://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
jeff carter
2012-04-05 19:00:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by hank alrich
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was
kind of homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition
being a great player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
Tuning? Banjo? Standard?  Can those three words be used in the same
sentence?
Tom from Texas
Move along, This doesn't concern you. Nothing to see here.
Next??
Do note that Earl's book is not a good place for a beginner to start.
Pete Wernick's is a worthy offering, and once a student is well into
that one Earl's can be a good next step.
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
I learned the banjo from Earl's book in my 16th summer (1975). I took
it slow and got pretty good that summer. I don't know what other books
were available back then, but I had a great time with it. And 36 years
of therapy later, I've got most of my marbles back...

--Jeff



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
http://www.youtube.com/user/jeffretrac
www.soundclick.com/jeffcarter
hank alrich
2012-04-05 21:01:27 UTC
Permalink
Post by jeff carter
I learned the banjo from Earl's book in my 16th summer (1975). I took
it slow and got pretty good that summer. I don't know what other books
were available back then, but I had a great time with it. And 36 years
of therapy later, I've got most of my marbles back...
--Jeff
There weren't other options back then, Jeff, for bluegrass banjo, so you
did what you had to do. <g> My first banjo book was Pete Seeger's, but
that ain't bluegrass pickin'.

For some it'll make no difference. For most, I contend Wernick's
_Bluegrass banjo_ will get a student going more easily and more quickly.
--
shut up and play your guitar * http://hankalrich.com/
http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusic
http://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Tony Weber
2012-04-05 23:23:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tom from Texas
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
Tuning? Banjo? Standard? Can those three words be used in the same
sentence?
Tom from Texas
Sure. Right up there with "Military Intelligence" and "Mature Male."
Rockhound57
2017-02-06 05:52:19 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 05 Apr 2012 16:23:46 -0700, Tony Weber
Post by Tony Weber
Post by Tom from Texas
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
Tuning? Banjo? Standard? Can those three words be used in the same
sentence?
Tom from Texas
Sure. Right up there with "Military Intelligence" and "Mature Male."
You still fucking your St. Bernard?

Jonathan
2012-04-05 19:10:25 UTC
Permalink
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Is this what you're calling standard tuning?

D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string

Thanks,
Jonathan
Jonathan
2012-04-05 20:44:36 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jonathan
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www....
Is this what you're calling standard tuning?
D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string
Thanks,
Jonathan
Sorry for the double post. Google Groups :(
Tony Weber
2012-04-05 23:32:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jonathan
Post by Jonathan
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www....
Is this what you're calling standard tuning?
D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string
Thanks,
Jonathan
Sorry for the double post. Google Groups :(
I'm starting to feel the same way about Google Groups as I use to about AOL.
Tony Done
2012-04-05 22:12:24 UTC
Permalink
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Post by Tony Weber
Yeah, he played a banjo. so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar
*http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Is this what you're calling standard tuning?

D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string

Thanks,
Jonathan

****************

You will also see it called open G, and it is a close relative of the tuning
commonly used for dobro.

Tony D
Jonathan
2012-04-05 17:46:36 UTC
Permalink
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Yeah, he played a banjo.  so what?
A chapter in the back of his book on playing banjo on building one is
what got me started as a luthier... a small 4 page section of that
chapter started me off as an inlay artist... Beyond that, few people
can say they single handedly changed an American music genre. An
American Icon.
Harv
***************
I have that book, and recall thinking that though his language was kind of
homely, he had obvious talents as a builder in addition being a great
player.
Tony D
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Thanks,
Jonathan
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Hank,

For clarity's sake, Is this what you're calling "standard tuning?"

D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string

Thanks!
Jonathan
hank alrich
2012-04-05 21:01:25 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jonathan
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
Hank,
For clarity's sake, Is this what you're calling "standard tuning?"
D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string
Thanks!
Jonathan
That's correct, Jonathon. Get Pete Wernick's book _Bluegrass Banjo_ or
his videos, etc.

http://www.drbanjo.com/drbshop/books/bluegrass-banjo
--
shut up and play your guitar * http://hankalrich.com/
http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusic
http://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Jonathan
2012-04-06 13:49:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jonathan
Post by hank alrich
Post by Jonathan
Does anyone know what tuning Scruggs used to record Foggy Mountain
Breakdown?
I also curious what tuning Eric Weissberg used to play the Deliverance
theme.
I'm thinking of taking up the banjo, but not sure what tuning to start
with.
Start with the standard tuning. "FMB" is in that, and so is "Dueling
Banjos".
Hank,
For clarity's sake, Is this what you're calling "standard tuning?"
D - 1st string
B - 2nd string
G - 3rd string
D - 4th string
G - 5th string
Thanks!
Jonathan
That's correct, Jonathon.  Get Pete Wernick's book _Bluegrass Banjo_ or
his videos, etc.
http://www.drbanjo.com/drbshop/books/bluegrass-banjo
--
shut up and play your guitar *http://hankalrich.com/http://www.youtube.com/walkinaymusichttp://www.sonicbids.com/HankandShaidri
Thanks!
Loading...